There was me, Rok, and my brother there. I was only on my third day of playing, Rok was about on the same, bit longer, and then there was my brother who had just started the game two hours ago.
After starting off nicely, meeting new folk and stuff, BEN and REAVER came along an convinced us to start up a settlement on the island.
They promptly tricked us into leading our boat there and setting up hearth fires.
After that, Ben posted a note in a Wicker basket and prompted Rok to read it. It read "Shut up bitch" and then Ben killed all three of us. Noobs trapped on an island with hearths set there as well.
Reaver abused the lift-boat glitch to lift our boat out of the water, and kept us stranded there. I had absolutely no idea, after just beginning to play.
I believe that this was harsh and unfair. Being tricked into a trap like that. We asked for him to stop, and instead he just murdered us three. It didn't seem like he was after LP or any personal items, but just for the griefing purpose. I find it's unbelievably unfair to trap noobs on an island and kill them off just because we didn't know any better.
Once again, their names are Ben and Reaver. They live in a village marked here.

I really believe this isn't fair. I just started the game. Literally my third day playing. I feel awful for all the hard effort I've put into the game, only to be lost by griefers.
Edit: I realize how much of my work I've lost now. Thanks to these two griefers, I've lost roughly half the work I had done. Including my Yeomanry.