Here are the facts:
1. One of our friends died by a guy asking "Where is my linen?" I don't know how many people go around doing that--I couldn't see any scents from this incident.
2. WhiskeyJack found another cave entrance that connected with our own, found our place, and did steal 4-6 steel. I was there, on my alt, talking to him, while he was searching throughout our place. We showed up with friends, and he quickly hearthed out of there. Yeah, we didn't target him.
3. 2 guys ran up and quickly murdered one of our other friends, and proceeded to quickly find the other cave entrance and get inside of our base (as we were just building up the palisade post to prevent this. I basically answered questions for them, like:
random guy: "Do you know who we are?"
me: "Do you know whiskeyjack, or are from the village of malaz, or something?"
random guy: "Sounds familier."
--Basically, I gave them a background to use. So they could have easily been lying. They were very quick about finding the connection to our cave, and stole all our metal and stuffs, destroyed our kiln, cupboards, etc. Could have been
random griefers.
Funny thing:
One of Whiskeyjack's village mates had the HS 1237, which we made a new villager there, and I must say, Whiskeyjack was quite welcoming.
Well, since our 2nd friend died, my village mates and that friend decided to rage at the village, and spawned at that hearth and attempted to destroy everything they could. In the midst of the action, the village mates destroyed Whiskey's hearth, and he had been gone for 3 hours already.................................................

Long story short, I could summon him anywhere, but I didn't have murder. Reapit had murder, so we tried to meet, took a good amount of time to find each other (he ran a good distance due to the 2 random guys incident), and by the time we were with each other, Whiskey had built a new hearth. Sad day :c
These are the facts.