by Rift » Fri Jul 31, 2009 1:18 pm
in my opinion, For killing something quickly at higher levels [strangle], uanrmed in the best... however any even slightly drawn out battle gives a sword+shield combo a advantage, and it only gets worse as time goes on. A sword+shield is the best for hunting, fighting ect EXCEPT in the one case where you are trying to kill someone in less then 30 seconds... since you can strangle someone without any initative points like the other instance attacks.
A battleaxe has a insane disadvatage because you need UNARMED to doge and MELEE to hit, so you have to lvl 2 things. the 1/3str+50 damage the axe gives you is nothing to sneeze at, however since i do over 100Damage with my fist, so while if i used a axe i would do over 150damage.... it's not that big of a deal, since i can attack much much faster with my fist then a axe. A shield is 150% as effective as a unarmed dodge, so its A LOT better for dodging attacks
Battleaxe=useless except against animals you can 1/2 hit.
Sword+shield=best in any fight longer then 30 seconds [shield uses melee, sword uses melee, you only need to lvl one skill], and best against any animal except those that you can't 1 hit kill but could with a battleaxe.
unarmed= Best if you have INSANELY high str and need to kill stuff in less then 30 seconds.