edit: ^^^^^ this guy - FUCK NO
Rhiannon wrote: "Joining a city that has a mine" = being a farm slave in most cases.
The reason for that is that the job of "farm slave" is typically in much higher demand than another smith. Once you have the scythe, the metal saw, the grinder, the cauldron etc etc, you don't really need that much more metal except to trade or when your clay/smith skill allows you to build a higher quality armor or such. "Farm slave" is to be quite honest a much more useful profession, a village always needs food, only occasionally needs metal. This is spoken as one such "slave" myself - I wouldn't trade the job for anything, the folks I live with would probably be most jealous if I told them my total char LP
Rhiannon wrote:Those cities don't want another miner/smither usually, they want cooks and farmers so THEY can mine and smith and will give them some metal farm equiptment..lol
Sure, let's have the village blacksmith move his slider from industry to nature and then we'll just flush all of that LP he put into smithing down the toilet, so a new guy can have a turn in the mine

Like I say, the reason the new guys to join a mine city don't typically become "mine slaves" (lol see wut i did thar) is because the demand for the job just isn't there.
If a "farm slave" were to come to our village, once they were set up they'd be outfitted with a scythe, metal plow, grinder, cauldron, all the good metal stuff that makes people want it so bad, along with armor and a weapon if they desired. This is assuming that person was contributing to the group as a whole, maybe other villages run differently but it works for us