This still looks very bad tbh. The fanmade one is way way better. How do you look at this and think it looks good? There is no flavor.
This fanmade one shows the ambient background, with the words haven and hearth coming out of a dark cave, which sets a tone. Yours just looks sterile. The frumpy monster also looks better than yours. You lose on all fronts.
Robertzen is part of the Misa lynch squad, and I'm still saying you should just take the L and use his. I don't care if the 4channers get another W on this point, because this is about promoting Haven in the best possible light before the steam release.