Divine Judgment: The Case of Willy Potter vs. Tartarus

[ChildhoodObesity]

Why on earth would somoene have not seperatedly walled charter stone, instead, have it in the middle of the village or something? Weird ...
However, I'd love to see a nuke only cause I can't read the stupid willy whateverpotter thing posts anymore.

thought we were boys mannnnnnn

[loftar]

But they where the ones taking the initiative and abusing the mechanic.

If you're going to keep insisting on this, I think you could at least try and counter the arguments made in the verdict.

im not even sure if it was supposed to be something someone should have reported or concerned as everything seemed to have worked the way it should to me...i mean, isnt it the security problem of those who got raided in this case?

Sure, but I think it's fair to say that it's muddy enough that they ought to have made a report just in case, and that not doing so displays less-than-optimal judgment. If they are open to "experimenting" with game mechanics, it seems only fair that they ought to open to it both ways. ^^

[MightySheep]

Why on earth would somoene have not seperatedly walled charter stone, instead, have it in the middle of the village or something? Weird ...
However, I'd love to see a nuke only cause I can't read the stupid willy whateverpotter thing posts anymore.

Pretty sure the willy people have their charterstone unwalled in the middle of their village same as us lol. People keep pointing out individual "security flaws" that arent actually flaws at all. It's only when these events (leaving gate open, unwalled charter, unticked box on charter) happen simulatenously is it a flaw.

It's like 20/20 hindsight OP. The only people who are really entitled to act condescending here are the ones who knew about this method of raiding beforehand, which is why dev shitposting is funny to read.

[Karede]

Very solid ruling. Good to have it definitively said that the visitor debuff is not a license to leave every gate open but rather a tool for community projects

[Astarisk]

Why on earth would somoene have not seperatedly walled charter stone, instead, have it in the middle of the village or something? Weird ...
However, I'd love to see a nuke only cause I can't read the stupid willy whateverpotter thing posts anymore.

Just have a look at the last wizard video posted.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0EfLRqBuoi4
Their charterstone is in the middle of the village, non walled.
But they where the ones taking the initiative and abusing the mechanic.

You can check devs response to this at the begining of this thread.

Our charterstone never has spawning enabled, a constantly changing password, and is behind two walls so no one but us can visit.

[dzielny_wojownik]

However, I'd love to see a nuke only cause I can't read the stupid willy whateverpotter thing posts anymore.

same here tbh

[sxasaaa]

Sure, but I think it's fair to say that it's muddy enough that they ought to have made a report just in case, and that not doing so displays less-than-optimal judgment. If they are open to "experimenting" with game mechanics, it seems only fair that they ought to open to it both ways. ^^

So our punishment is basically a fun way of making people report their bugs? Well thought. Although I need to agree it's a cool idea, let's see how long our little Azkaban can defend itself from all the kinds of shit.

[Tonkyhonk]

Sure, but I think it's fair to say that it's muddy enough that they ought to have made a report just in case, and that not doing so displays less-than-optimal judgment. If they are open to "experimenting" with game mechanics, it seems only fair that they ought to open to it both ways. ^^

whether it's muddy or not is your decision, however, is anything muddy enough to the point for you to officially encourage others to bugraid anyone in your game now?

[sxasaaa]

I just hope it's only a week or something, any other case is stupid.

[Granger]

Not anyone, only the ones who broke the alpha contract of 'report first, then exploit'.