New Brodgar - War of Newb Defense

[Redempter]

@Redempter

I have a question. Based on the IRC log of the attempted peace talk, a demand of the master key(?) was made by Brodgar. Do you feel this as a reasonable reparation or not? I am asking this because this has been one of the controversial factor in the breakdown in negotiation.

I wasn't the one negociating so I cannot say if this was reasonable demand or not but I understand the motive behind such a huge demand. The thing was, New Brodgar wanted to be safe and the only way to be safe from R'lyeh was to have something that we could use against them in case of future attack.

I know R'lyeh had no way to trust New Brodgar but New Brodgar had no reason to trust R'lyeh as well, in our eyes they were an ally of Ainran, one of the worst factions in the Hearthland, what were we to do? Trust them and wait for our ultimate demise?

[Patchouli_Knowledge]

I see. Thank you for answering my question from your perspective.

[dageir]

@Redempter

I have a question. Based on the IRC log of the attempted peace talk, a demand of the master key(?) was made by Brodgar. Do you feel this as a reasonable reparation or not? I am asking this because this has been one of the controversial factor in the breakdown in negotiation.

I wasn't the one negociating so I cannot say if this was reasonable demand or not but I understand the motive behind such a huge demand. The thing was, New Brodgar wanted to be safe and the only way to be safe from R'lyeh was to have something that we could use against them in case of future attack.

I know R'lyeh had no way to trust New Brodgar but New Brodgar had no reason to trust R'lyeh as well, in our eyes they were an ally of Ainran, one of the worst factions in the Hearthland, what were we to do? Trust them and wait for our ultimate demise?

Are you safe now?
If you succeeded and brought them down, and their allies yield, yes you have some breathing space. If you are now the biggest and strongest faction,
(you are without a doubt the faction with most "media cover") and have alienated a veteran faction and also attracting attention from others, your days as a village/faction is soon numbered if your group is not big enough or active enough
to outmatch any other group or a combination of groups 24/7.
What is your future recruitment strategy anyways?

[Tonkyhonk]

The thing was, New Brodgar wanted to be safe and the only way to be safe from R'lyeh was to have something that we could use against them in case of future attack.

i hope that wasnt the true intention.

[overtyped]

For an outsider it looks like the ideals of Brodgar has been left, an a new raider faction has arisen.

"Whoever fights monsters should see to it that in the process he does not become a monster.
And if you gaze long enough into an abyss, the abyss will gaze back into you."

Friedrich Nietzsche

If broder is a raider faction, please list one example of an unprovoked attack.
This should be easy enough??

[RedKGB]

I am glad to see what NB is as I was saying they were over a month ago.

At least others are now more informed.

[overtyped]

I am glad to see what NB is as I was saying they were over a month ago.

At least others are now more informed.

If brodger is a raider faction, please list one example of an unprovoked attack.

[dageir]

For an outsider it looks like the ideals of Brodgar has been left, an a new raider faction has arisen.

"Whoever fights monsters should see to it that in the process he does not become a monster.
And if you gaze long enough into an abyss, the abyss will gaze back into you."

Friedrich Nietzsche

If broder is a raider faction, please list one example of an unprovoked attack.
This should be easy enough??

I do not like to go ad hominem here, but the fact that you are associated with, or in New Brodgar, confirms that you most likely
are a raider group. No offence intended.

[RedKGB]

If broder is a raider faction, please list one example of an unprovoked attack.
This should be easy enough??

The idea that this is the only way to prove being a raider or not is cute.

[overtyped]

If broder is a raider faction, please list one example of an unprovoked attack.
This should be easy enough??

The idea that this is the only way to prove being a raider or not is cute.

Really...? Brodgar will never attack unless attacked first and you call us raiders?
If self defense is your definition of raider, then everyone is a raider, even the farmers, because they could presumably be attacked and try to run ( running is also an act of raiding)