Hi,
Since the patch that fixed a bug involving barrels, I have had eight trees not level up as expected when potting them.
According to the formula posted on the wiki (and it's been accurate all of W15 for me so far) my trees should have easily gainged 10-15 points of Q even with the +/- factor.
Instead the potted tree has resulted in a nearly 20q decrease from the seed being used. The water and herbalist table are both higher Q than the seed. The pot is equal to the seed in Q. The lower component is my soil, however it is not that far behind. It is acting as if the water is 1/3 it's actual quality.
I've tried two separate runs of four trees today. Both had the same result. (Same four pots, same herbalist table, same soil, same water and only a 3pt Q difference on the seeds used.)
Thank you,
Krool