azrid wrote:What a bad idea.
Its either going to be too powerful or way too situational to be worth the time to develop.
We already have a lot of different ways to bypass rubbing sticks I don't think we need another one.
As long as it only works outside during the day and takes longer than sticks, I don't see how it would be OP or too situational. Sticks would ideally be more time-efficient as long as you pay attention, this would just allow you to set and forget the process of starting a fire at the cost of extra time taken to do so, instead of alt tabbing and missing the firebrand window.
Since it only works during the day, you'd still need to carry around other firestarters. It's essentially an option to slow down the consumption of matches/flint & steel at the price of time.