Limit posts to C&I to one new thread/day

[Liss12]

Imagine being so upset that you don't have as many ideas as somebody else that you try to censor him.

The problem there is that his bright ideas push other threads to the bottom of the page. How offten people even bother to check second page of this forum?

[VDZ]

Ideas outright rejected by jorb and loftar wouldn't even show up.

The problem with this is that sometimes, devs disagree with an idea but community support is so overwhelming they decide to make the change anyways, as was the case with for example 'Mine Support Changes are Awful.'. If these kinds of threads get filtered before they can get posted, the community wouldn't be able to properly voice their opinions.

Also it would prevent further 'remove midges' threads from being made, and midges should be either drastically overhauled or straight up removed. Fuck midges.

[dafels]

make shubla pay a dollar for every post he makes

[DDDsDD999]

Signed

[Audiosmurf]

make shubla pay

[Burinn]

Is the issue that people feel like their Good Ideas™ are pushed off the front page by Shubla posting what they think are Bad Ideas™? Are you worried your Good Idea™ won't get the attention it """deserves""" because it's off the first page of active topics? Do people think Jorb/Loftar won't read your thread if it isn't on the first page of active topics? Is that seriously what the problem is?


People aren't posting in your threads because they either don't think it's good or there is nothing else to talk about. Not because BIG BAD GUY SHUBLA BUMPED MY POST OFF THE ACTIVE TOPICS FIRST PAGE!!!

Talk about entitlement lmao. I hate having to "defend" shubla but christ this is such an embarrassing thread. If your ideas are good people will post in your threads. If you have a huge effort post it should not come as a surprise that people are going to have a harder time responding to it compared to "add a new bird".

[boshaw]

...

Calm down, your boyfriend will still be able to make daily idea threads while thinking further about his others before posting them the next day to improve the suggestion delivery.

[Burinn]

...

Calm down shubla-lite, your boyfriend will still be able to make daily idea threads while thinking further about his others before posting them the next day to improve the suggestion delivery.

Can you respond to the content of my post?



Why is a thread that should be a post in Plea even in C&I? Talk about irony.

[MagicManICT]

Ideas outright rejected by jorb and loftar wouldn't even show up.

The problem with this is that sometimes, devs disagree with an idea but community support is so overwhelming they decide to make the change anyways, as was the case with for example 'Mine Support Changes are Awful.'. If these kinds of threads get filtered before they can get posted, the community wouldn't be able to properly voice their opinions.

Which, when you consider the other things I have posted here, is exactly my point. I, or any other volunteer here, am not a proper judge of what a good or bad thread is because I don't have any more inside information about the direction of game development than anyone else. Even jorb or loftar can't be the best judge of what a good or bad idea is because they can sometimes be influenced by what the players think about things. The best they could try to do is filter out "troll posts," and even that can be hard to judge.

So, what, exactly, is the criteria that we should limit C&I by? The only answer I can come up with is "None."

[Ardennesss]

Ideas outright rejected by jorb and loftar wouldn't even show up.

The problem with this is that sometimes, devs disagree with an idea but community support is so overwhelming they decide to make the change anyways, as was the case with for example 'Mine Support Changes are Awful.'. If these kinds of threads get filtered before they can get posted, the community wouldn't be able to properly voice their opinions.

Which, when you consider the other things I have posted here, is exactly my point. I, or any other volunteer here, am not a proper judge of what a good or bad thread is because I don't have any more inside information about the direction of game development than anyone else. Even jorb or loftar can't be the best judge of what a good or bad idea is because they can sometimes be influenced by what the players think about things. The best they could try to do is filter out "troll posts," and even that can be hard to judge.

So, what, exactly, is the criteria that we should limit C&I by? The only answer I can come up with is "None."

So with a straight face you're telling me that if I wanted to make 20 C&I threads per day with ideas ranging from "Add a new blue stone!" to "Add a wound for logging in!" this is acceptable and there should be no action taken against me? Because that's literally what shubla does. He just spams dipshit ideas to up his post count and piss people off and push actual ideas off the first page.