Some ideas from 1 window player

[jorb]

large thread with various, unrelated, things.

its my list what hard to endure to me, every point not need to be related each other

Please avoid making grab bag threads with multiple unrelated suggestions. Give each idea its own thread so posters can discuss its merits, so that ideas aren't overshadowed by more popular ideas, and so that they might be found later using the search tool.

The Rules

[ctopolon3]

but is so comfortablу to edit it like list. mb 1 thread from 1 user on first page of "Critique & Ideas" better than 20 threads from each user?

[Beezer12Washingbeard]

Of course it's easier for you. But you're not the one who needs to read through and parse it if you have any hope of ever seeing the suggestions put to use, are you?

The devs (of not just this game, but ANY game) are occupied with running the game itself. Game devs are also often inundated with suggestions from enthusiastic players who have all sorts of ideas--good, bad, and otherwise--of how the game could be better. Many of the suggestions (regardless of the game) are going to be repetitive, vague, or vague & repetitive, like low-detail lists of "this and this and this and this and this."

Most developers don't have the time or attention needed to try and read your mind or parse a long list of unrelated ideas and how they could fit into the existing architecture. You've seen how many threads jorb has read and replied to. The forum itself is already a big list of unrelated ideas. Make their job easier and at the very least, if you've got a big list, you could try splitting the list into a few smaller chunks of somewhat-related ideas. But ultimately if a dev asks you to make separate threads for unrelated suggestions, just fuggin do it, it costs you next to nothing and if a mod thinks you're spamming the board they'll probably let you know.

[omocho]

His suggestions are all trash anyway so it's easier if they just stay in one single thread, and die in one single thread. Lets be honest, none of this will ever happen.

[Beezer12Washingbeard]

Fair enough, but way I see it that's not my call to make. I mean, I had no idea wtf this could mean and thought it was more nonsense (the only part I understand is the first five words):

need alt without DA to cast_iron->bloom->cast->bloom->top_metal
mb it will be cast->bloom->wrought->steel->bloom->top_metal

But apparently jorb was able to parse it and said maybe, so what do I know.

[ctopolon3]

need alt without DA to cast_iron->bloom->cast->bloom->top_metal
mb it will be cast->bloom->wrought->steel->bloom->top_metal

its about the double/triple crit metal with alts without Deep Artifice & Metallurgy. normal player will buy all skill = cant doble/triple crit metal = have no best metal