by Zamte » Sat Aug 29, 2015 2:49 am
Jorb, Loftar, I like you guys. I've spent probably thousands of hours in your games, posting on your forums, talking to friends about them, even making new friends in them. You make interesting games that people can enjoy, and I'm all for you guys making money on them. I still think this is a jorbtroll, but if it isn't then I think you're going in the wrong direction.
Requiring a regular commitment to paying for a persistent product is hard to convince people on even for large games with fully paid staff and giant server farms. You guys are on your own, with limited resources and somewhat slow development cycles. If you charge people a monthly fee to play then they are going to expect you to match that persistent dedication with some of your own. Are you going to be able to go at it full time and really push the game?
I personally would much rather see you charge a small fee for entry now. Call it an early access price, make it $15-20. A little high for some, but as it is one time then many will do it anyways. Even with only a few hundred players that should give you guys some starting money to invest back into it and get it to a place where it can really justify a monthly payment model. I'm not sure $10 is in the cards to start with, but you'd be making something.
Consumer confidence is already hard to build in online games, and most of them don't have permadeath, frequent wipes, and a world which gives other people free reign to take their time, money, and enjoyment away for kicks. You guys deserve to make money, but you can't just add the same cookie cutter monetization that other vastly different games use on without warning and expect it to go over well.
Good luck with the game. I hope you figure out a way to make it work. You guys have many good ideas and I'd love to see them get more exposure in the long run. I had planned to come back for this, and I still may down the road, but for now I can't justify another subscription when I'm paying for FF14 and have limited time. The game is just too deep and too likely to suck me in.