Fish from shore junk pile

[shubla]

Somebody catched a fish, threw it away, so now I can find it from beach?
Weird!

[MagicManICT]

does this really belong in C&I? This has been a thing since these were implemented. Anything that is dropped in the water, by intent or accident, can pop out through the beach trash or fishing.

[Sevenless]

Alright lets make this C&I:

Instead of getting the fish, you should get a curio of the same quality that the fish was. Small rotten fish, Big rotten fish, Huge rotten fish.

It's really weird to fish up a fish when lure fishing that's not a fish you can catch at that node anyway. Or "catching" lake fish in the ocean, etc.

[linkfanpc]

Alright lets make this C&I:

Instead of getting the fish, you should get a curio of the same quality that the fish was. Small rotten fish, Big rotten fish, Huge rotten fish.

It's really weird to fish up a fish when lure fishing that's not a fish you can catch at that node anyway. Or "catching" lake fish in the ocean, etc.

This please.

[Ysh]

One time I am on quest for salmon fish. I spend minutes or maybe even days searching for the lair of these fishes. At first, I will only have option for these fish once every one hundred casts of my fishing rod's spell. These scout fish, as I assume they will be, are very cute and very clever and easily evade my hooks. Eventually though, my search takes me to the ends of the land where there is small lake. It is here that I find the home of these fish. With my mana nearly depleted, the fishing casts become impotent. A mere one in one hundred chance for this salmon fish, but I will get the chance every time I cast in this locale. After some minutes of trials, I become accustomed to this plopping sound after I try to angle for a catch. Some time this plop will not come, and I am very excited to look at my inventory and see which new kind of stone or tree seed I fish up. Then it finally will happen. I hear no plop. I check inventory. There is new fish there. It is two tile fish. Success! This is what I am thinking. After some closer looks, however, this is not salmon at all. It is some trash fish, I suppose. This was quite the deception to me, and I do not fond of it.

Eventually I catch this salmon fish and ingest it to gain its powers.