MagicManICT wrote:AtoB wrote:And I'm going to say it one last time too: The masks the people are made to wear to protect others against a killer virus do jack shit in that regard as they are technically unable to filter aerosols. Wearing them is a sole gesture of submission to authorities.
100+ years of medical science says otherwise. If simple face masks didn't work to prevent the spread of disease, doctors wouldn't wear them in the surgical theater. For most of that century, those face masks weren't much different than what you can make at home right now. Are they perfect? By no means. But they are effective, even if they are not medical grade.
I completely agree with you that in scenarios like a surgical theater there is a measurable effect for masks used by trained professionals, but I completely disagree with you on attaching a positive effect on them being mandated onto the general population in corona
theater (pun intended).
I'll ignore your lame attempt on an ad hominem. Over the years I came to know you a bit (though certainly only through what you wrote in the forum) and I'm stunned to see that you seem to have suddenly lost the ability of critical thinking (that you had demonstrated repeatedly, for years) when it comes to the corona narrative.
Take a look at it and ask yourself if you're just being stubborn, or if you truly believe science is right about everything else, but wrong here.
I kindly ask you to ask yourself the exact same question.
And in an attempt to find some truth in things... let's do some science, shall we?
Let's start with some plots by Robert Koch Institute (government authority on infectious diseases), from their pulmonary sentinel that is regarded as representative for the german population. This is official data, measured, verified, undisputed and free of any speculation:
2018/2019

2019/2020

Please explain to me how rhinovirus infections can multiply, about twice of last years magnitude, with people now wearing masks as mandated and many even wearing them not only in areas where use of them is mandated but all the time (even outside when alone)?
With this question kept in mind, let's look at what has happened in the hospitals here in Germany:

To make it easier for you here the translation:
Dark orange is COVID-19 cases in hospital treatment, light orange is COVID-19 cases in ICU treatment.
Yellow text top-right reads 'effect of the individual measures gets visible 14 days later', as of this the dates for the marked points in the chart have been moved to the right to reflect the average timespan between infection and hospitalization.
The steep ramp up at the beginning isn't stemming from exponential growth but is simply from ramping up the PCR testing.
As notable events we had (I added some that have not been marked in the chart):
- Start of 2020-03: some events get canceled. Difficult to measure because of lack of data.
- 2020-03-13: Peak of infections in Germany (though this information took some weeks to surface)
- 2020-03-18: Government asks population to wash hands, cough into armpit instead of hands, keep some distance to others and avoid unneeded contacts. This very likely has been the measure with the highest effect as people upped their personal hygiene - mainly through following a simple but obvious idea a certain Ignaz Semmelweis came up with (around 150 years ago) a bit more often: wash your hands.
- 2020-03-23: Lockdown. Outlets for food, fuel, healthcare, banks and public transport stay open unchanged. Likely unwarranted (hence: unconstitutional) as the downward trend had already been initiated.
- The following peak solely consists of patients being 'imported' from other EU countries to relief their hospitals.
- 2020-04-09: German chancellor Merkel settles onto 'epidemic will only end with the general availability of a vaxine' narrative. People begin to question the official narrative, Querdenken-711 forms as a protest group in Stuttgart.
- 2020-04-17: Querdenken-711 successfully sued the local authorities up to the Bundesverfassungsgericht (= german surpreme court) which ruled that demonstrations can not simply be forbidden 'because corona'. Demonstrations against the way corona is handled, which had been denied by authorities up till now 'because people would get infected and die', start to happen in Stuttgart on a weekly basis. No observable COVID-19 effects.
- 2020-04-26: Robert Koch Institute declares the seasonal influenza season 2019/2020 as ended. No SARS-CoV-2 has been detected in the pulmonary sentinel ever since.
- 2020-04-27: Masks get mandated county-wide in closed public places (shops etc.) and public transport. Around the same time barriers get installed at counters, in busses, whatnot. No observable COVID-19 effect.
- 2020-06-06: Black lives matter demonstrations, several cities with 15-20K participants, massive non-compliance regarding masks and keeping distance. No observable COVID-19 effect.
- Around 2020-06-15: schools and child care facilities reopen. No observable COVID-19 effect.
- 2020-06-18: Mass 'outbreak' in one of our biggest meat plants, over 1500 'infected' (all working the the slaughtering section). No observable COVID-19 effect.
- 2020-08-01: Querdenken-711 organizes the 'Festival of peace, end of the pandemic' Demonstration in Berlin, Between 20k and 500k (depending on who you ask) people who disbelieve the official narrative and oppose the measures taken as unwarranted (and of this: unconstitutional) gathered, nearly complete non-compliance regarding masks and keeping distance. No observable COVID-19 effect.
Is that science enough for you to grasp that there is reasoning behind the conclusion that masks, in the form they have been imposed onto people
and for the alleged purpose of protection against SARS-CoV-2, are useless? That people with this perspective might have
thought about it, opposed to your suspicion of them having jumped to conclusions because they are stupid?
Please keep in mind that I argue based on data from and events in Germany, a country that had
skipped certain things others countries did to massively up their local death count, among others:
- Reducing the capacity of the hospital system to be on the brink of being overwhelmed by normal seasonal flu on a regular basis, leading to hospitals being overwhelmed.
- Moving people with active pulmonary diseases out of hospitals into elder care facilities to infect the ones there.
- Paying absurd amounts to health care institutions and funeral homes for the checkmark in the 'COVID-19' square.
- Paying even more to health care providers that for COVID-19 patients that get intubated and ventilated (likely to death: ventilating someone with a pulmonary infection, especially in combination to immune system suppressants, has a high chance to be fatal).
- Pushing stuff like hydroxychloroquin to be taken by the handful as a preventive measure, not only exceeding safe doses but possibly also ignoring counter-indications like flavism - likely killing plenty.
- ...