Haven and Heart was so cool! The way you needed to band together to survive and build your town, making things simpler to craft was an experience that I've never had in any other MMO.
I like crafting, farming, fishing, blacksmithing, and just managing things. Camelot Unchained has me giddy at the prospect of being so good at something that you could be famous, and the amount of customization in making the items themselves makes me feel like you could have a distinct style--but something that in-depth is a long way off.
BDO was fun for a month, but it felt pretty aimless and like I was so limited by time, like there wasn't enough things to do actively or to manage without ending up with loads of downtime.
I'm going to try Wurm and Tale of Toast (when the servers are up), but does anyone have any suggestions for what else I could play?