Think about this, new world starts, 1400 players. 1 Year down the road, 200+ online.
I absolutely love the game, I tried to get into it again, but really what was the point? I travel to the extended portion of the map, and high q areas are claimed. Everything revolves around clay, and people seem to claim the high q first.
Also there is a wide rang of fields and interests that appeal to all types of gamers. The problem with an old world is that it only suits those that are top of the food chain, either buy hoarding nodes or killing noobs to prevent competition (which is fine to an extent). There is an element that people seem to forget is that this is a sandbox game, yet when the world reaches a particular age, you are left in the mercy to those who have the oldest characters, which limits what you can do.
When I first played, there was a thrill of survival. Many players, some blood thirsty and some peaceful. If you were peaceful and somebody tried to murder you, you could fight back or get a quick wood wall up and your safe. Now the gap between players is waaaaaaaaaaayyyyyyy to long. EVE also has a time based lving system, a 1-2 month old toon can still very much kill a 6-7 year old toon. This is done by making PvP more skill based as apposed to Gear based. IF you can not do this, which is why I believe that HandH dose great in new worlds and population and dies at late world, then the game absolutely need system resets. When you have an alt that is only fed str to reach 400+ and given a sledge hammer, can bust the wall down and destroy the only defense of a noob or young player in a matter of mins, Then there is serious balance issues that need to be addressed.
recent experience: pvp active, 10-30q items. Made a homestead, left scents, moments later alt with a sledge busts down wooden wall, absolutely murdered by a older toon with axe of the 12, dragon helm and purple robe. Having a lv advantage is fine. Having no form of defense is not ok. As for those that say "leave no scents" pvp, crime esc is a very active and strong game mechanic and appeals to many people. One should not ignore a aspect of the game, to actually be able to play the game.
I was introduced to the game, due to the crazy of, "ATTENTION WORLD 7 IS ABOUT TO START FOR HAVEN AND HEARTH!" I honestly believe, a world reset would attract more players, thus making the game more popular, which would help with the promotion of this absolutely genius and wonderful game.