Battle Ettiquite-Just a quick thought.

[Delamore]

If your strong enough to kill someone, whats the point in destroying your chances of a second visit. A raid never was to kill if you look into the past, Raiders would enter villages, show their strength, take what they want and then leave them half alive. Only to come back a few months later...

Yeah but the difference here is that if you don't get them while they're not all online, they'll come to your town when you're not all online and tada you're all dead instead.

This is what I am trying to work out, what is the need to kill. I mean could they not have just hindered your ability to do anything by taking all the shit you had laying around instead. UNTIL something is done about the ability to kill offline (I not caring how or when or whatever) Murder shouldn't be used 'lightly' by anyone, good, bad or goon.

If Goons come and raid your village, stealing everything worth value and 'burn' down a couple of constructions of high qual. BUT don't kill you just knock you out. A vendetta of death isn't called for. Do Gooders just go to Goon land and knock out their people so they can 'retrieve' the stolen goods and in return tear down some of the Goon Constructions. No one gets killed, everyone has their fun and then you just start again with what you have left...

You mean the people that had plans to kill me on their private forum before I had done anything this map?
You need to go out and play the game rather than suggesting all this baseless shit.

[sabinati]

i said most of my posts. you cited three examples, which is about 0.2% of my posts. i don't bother being especially constructive when i don't think there's really anywhere good to go with an idea. you still mad i wouldn't sell you that linen, little buddy?

[Neyvn]

i said most of my posts. you cited three examples, which is about 0.2% of my posts. i don't bother being especially constructive when i don't think there's really anywhere good to go with an idea. you still mad i wouldn't sell you that linen, little buddy?

Hmmmm, just 0.2% of your posts huh...
Since last month nearly half of your posts in Ideas and Critic forum have started with a No, Just no... With no other reasoning for your denial to someone attempting an idea. Or heck you seem to just post to post. Giving no other reason to other then to be there. Like those people that stand in crowds for no other reason to be in the photo...

And no not caring about the linen. Never was a problem, I moved on and cared less about it later, tell the truth had forgotten about it till you brought it up. I just get annoyed by people like you who act like they are better then someone else but spend almost all their time telling others they suck. Ha, still makes me chuckle when you said, Creative Criticism. Ha...


~-~-~_~-~-~_~-~-~_~-~-~

Delamore, it is not baseless shit if I am thinking of a way to stop what happened to you, Gaidan and others in the past that were playing this game until they died. Some stay yes I know that, but how many chucked a hissy and left. Besides what did you spend most of your time on the last map doing, granted I wasn't there long enough to know whats what. BUT you kinda set yourself up as the bad guy and chose to play that role, heck you did little in the way to say otherwise. If you had done something else or perhaps decided to play it a little less, well, assy. Perhaps those characters would still be alive. Imagine if you did do what I have been thinking.

Would you still be 'dead'???

[Delamore]

If Gaiadin wasn't killed, I'd still be dead.

[Gaiadin]

If Gaiadin wasn't killed, I'd still be dead.

That's probably true. But I would also probably still be playing. To be fair though that isn't the only reason I stopped. We had basically reached the end of the game thus far, having 1 of every mine except silver and mostly HQ everything. Maybe after the full server reset we'll come test the new shit.

[sabinati]

Since last month nearly half of your posts in Ideas and Critic forum have started with a No, Just no... With no other reasoning for your denial to someone attempting an idea.

http://www.havenandhearth.com/forum/search.php?st=30&sk=t&sd=d&author=sabinati&fid%5B%5D=5&ch=1000

you're wrong.

[theTrav]

To be fair though that isn't the only reason I stopped. We had basically reached the end of the game thus far, having 1 of every mine except silver and mostly HQ everything.

Can I have your gold mine?

Since last month nearly half of your posts in Ideas and Critic forum have started with a No, Just no... With no other reasoning for your denial to someone attempting an idea.

you're wrong.

Seconded. Sabinati does do that more than anyone else, but he also posts more than anyone else, and quite often it's approval / proper criticism / new ideas.

[Jackard]

Hmmm, I wonder were you have seen more of my so call ideas. Cause I don't think I ever have given any in large amounts...
Not once did I say anything about a PvP toggle, this is a PLAYERS thought about how we can have less complaints over deaths when someone goes and feels like a little raid. If you have to take another step to kill someone, don't take it. THATS all I have said you gits....

Learn to read between the lines, you blithering idiot. Requiring both parties to consent before they can kill each other is essentially the same thing as a pvp toggle. Did you think you could trick others into supporting it by using different words, or did you just not think at all? Can you even comprehend how easily this and other toggle suggestions would be abused?

Since last month nearly half of your posts in Ideas and Critic forum have started with a No, Just no... With no other reasoning for your denial to someone attempting an idea. Or heck you seem to just post to post. Giving no other reason to other then to be there. Like those people that stand in crowds for no other reason to be in the photo...

lol you are blinded by indignation. if only you had the wit to see there are times when a suggestion is so terrible, no explanation is needed for a simple "no"

[eql]

My thought is about battle itself. IF I understand it correct, never having to fight another Hearthling before, when you battle, you attack the SHP first right, like how the animals deal damage, that means that you need to take an extra step to Murder someone right, or activate a CrimeSkill right.

IF its not like that ignore the rest of this post, if it is, continue.

Wait - you are uncertain how basic combat works, but you still suggest "improvements" to it?

he was right about how combat works though, so pointless post. i havent seen you come up with any good, well grounded ideas so you cant assume the role of a critic and try to topple everyones ideas. infact, this guy in his first post didnt even suggest any game mechanic improvements. he was simply on about battle etiquette and honour etc.

[Jackard]

i havent seen you come up with any good, well grounded ideas

only because your anger has blinded yourself to my greatness