As the topic suggests, our small settlement of Innsmouth was the target of a theft some hours ago. The place was absolutely riddled with scents - I packed some food and followed them, and they let to a place called Barrenburg, quite a ways from my place. The thief in question was not online, but his hearthfire was inside the village walls. Asked around a bit, and the other villagers seemed like good enough folk.
Anyways, my place is by no means a very wealthy nor a flashy one, so the silk, wrought and cast iron and other things that were taken were of quite some value to us, and the people of Innsmouth are not happy.
I'm not sure if Barrenburg caters to thieves - if my things could be returned, I'd let the matter slide. There are other solutions, if that fails.
The ball is, as they say, in your court. Looking forward to hearing from someone who runs things there.