This thread is for bragging about all the huge fish you caught (and for determining what kind of fish there are).
I've just caught a brill, fishing in a river with a plant fibre line, bone hook and an earthworm. Moon is in the waning phase, and by it's position I'd say it's about 4AM. Brill gives 1str and 1dex.
*edit*
Different bait, everything else the same:
Lake - earthworm: perch
Lake - woodfish: roach
River - tin fly: roach
Also, rock lobster sucks monkey balls. I've never caught anything with mine. It's just q10, though.
Apparently, roach is the new perch. I've caught them with just about every type of bait. They give int and dex, though, so they're not completely unwelcome.