Every single time people complain about the same things. Instead of simply resetting, they should also address some of those issues.
Let's see a few:
Vets advantage over new characters
This is a non-issue. A vet has to constantly play to keep on top, or they fall behind. A new player has a much faster progress curve, since they don't need to raise quality from scratch. Between scavenging and trading, you can get some pretty nice things in a matter of days, stuff that would take months to get on your own.
Ruins everywhere
Seeing ruins everywhere, while fun for scavenging, makes the world feel old and abandoned. New players often look for wild areas, where you can't see traces of other settlements, which becomes almost impossible at this point.
I see two possible fixes: much faster decay, or an expanding map.
- Faster decay would mean that claims would go down after just a few days of inactivity, and once they fall everything would decay in a week or so (including pavements and buildings). This would also require for terrain to regenerate to its former status, including trees, boulders, and so on. Only then it would look like a fresh area, and not some abandoned place.
- Expanding map would mean that every few weeks/months, a new area of the map would be uncovered. New characters would spawn there instead of the older areas. This would give new players what they want, while adding an interesting option for vets who might want to explore new stuff or even move (maybe to make a new realm).
Claimed resources
Old issue, hard to fix. The only way I can think of would be preventing claims (including vclaim) to cover it AND adding a buffer area around it that prevents people from building a small palisade to close them off (also, I wouldn't allow for hf in that area, but that's another issue). But I realize it's not that easy...
This is also the only "real" issue for new players, since joining now means having access to pretty much no localized resources. While some you can live without, other are crafting reagents needed for your progression.
Those are the three main issues I hear every time we talk about this. Unless they get solved, resetting the world only means giving it a few fresh months before someone start complaining about that again.