More player autonomy and letting people control their environment in a sandbox game seems rly good to me. The thing I don't like about it is the general development pattern of:
1) add some bullshit that makes the game objectively worse (winter, realms, truffles, pepper, belt rework, sleds/skiis, whales, PVP archery)
2) people complain for literal years that this obviously very bad thing is bad
3) add a chore to circumvent the original mechanic that was identified as making the game worse almost immediately
4) things are worse than before the original implementation, but people are relieved that it's not as bad as before
Just admit when something didn't work and yeet it instead of wasting your time putting bandaids on bandaids on bandaids. You could just make winter not fuck over plowed tiles/trees, not freeze water more than 1-3 tiles out, and give sleds/skiis no passengers with normal but faster movement behaviors and winter would be fine even if kindof ugly.