AlexNT wrote:Genabeton wrote:And anyway, as the classic wrote: "What is our life? The game!".
The classic you're referring to was writing in Russian, where "game" and "acting" literally are the same word ("игра"), and therefore present an ambiguity. And as he wrote that he was piggibacking off of another classic, whose words were "All the world's a stage, And all the men and women merely players". The second quote is very obviously about "acting" (aka "larping"), as Shakespeare likens the World to theater. Illustrates my previous point about confusing "game" and "larping" perfectly, imo.
Now let us turn to "Oxford languages" (as given by Google):
game
noun
1.
a form of play or sport, especially a competitive one played according to rules and decided by skill, strength, or luck.
2.
a complete episode or period of play, ending in a definite result.
"a baseball game".
If you think about the first games humans played, or if you look at how animals play (e.g. dogs and cats), a "game" is always a repetitive activity, meant to build up skill / experience in a safe(er) / easier environment in preparation for the "real thing", originally most commonly -- hunting. Today, the "preparation" part is mostly gone, but our animal instincts still compel us to spend our free time in "games" (we find games enjoyable, because originally they helped us survive). Therefore the repetitive nature (rounds), skill / experience building, and competitiveness/scoring -- all remain important parts of what a "game" (not play / acting, aka larping) is.
"Emergent gameplay" is mostly a persistent myth in the gaming industry. I've watched for 20 years different studios and projects peddle the idea, only to consistently and firmly fall on their face in the end. I'm not buying that shit anymore. And since you like classics, here's one for you:
"When a community has no color differentiation of pants, it has no goal, and when there is no goal...".TLDR: those of us requesting 3 mo resets -- want to play one common multiplayer "game" (according to common rules), not to play a "performance" (inside of which some will end up inventing their own individual "games" that they will essentially play solo, like you're alluding to). Simple as that.
You are picking on words, this happens when there is nothing to answer on the merits. The words that "all life is a game" were said by a gambler and refer to luck. For Shakespeare, it was relevant to analyze acting and hypocrisy, which is also a game. I am talking about the game in a broad sense, so both options are suitable. If you resort to such a detailed analysis of my words, be kind enough to analyze the entire text, otherwise I will not understand whether you have missed the whole point or are ignoring it. Your arguments are based on some rules of the game havenandhearth that do not exist and cannot exist, and on the fact that this is correct because it was like this before and this is how it is accepted. Here I refrain from commenting. The quote about social inequality that you highlighted in bold, what is it for? I suppose you think there will be no goal? Calm down, for you everything will be the same as it was, you just won't need to reinvent the wheel every time you want to ride. And the most important thing is that the game will have a future. I am talking about one permanent world for everyone, in which everyone will be able to reset themselves at least every three weeks or, over many years of leisurely play, build something truly interesting that will be a landmark for new players, for example. Thank you for your attention,
AlexNT, but, I'm sorry, I can no longer take you seriously.
PS: Herman's aria "What is our life" from composer Pyotr Tchaikovsky's opera "The Queen of Spades"
based on the story of the same name by Alexander Pushkin.
"What is our life? A game!
Good and evil, only dreams.
Work, honesty, fairy tales for women,
Who is right, who is happy here, friends,
Today you, and tomorrow me.
What is true - death is one,
Like the shore of the sea of vanity.
She is a refuge for all of us,
Who is dearer to her of us, friends,
Today you, and tomorrow me.
So give up the fight,
Catch the moment of luck,
Let the loser cry,
Let the loser cry,
Cursing his fate."