dageir wrote:Having a few gadgets and roof over your head does not make you well off in western society. And it does not make you not poor. Everything is relative...
I was going to put this in a PM, but I feel it's important to do this publicly.I respect your ability to recognize the bias in the media and admit the biased influence it has on your perspective. There are many points that you make with which I agree. And the few with which I disagree, I appreciate the fact that you stick to the points and dont get lost in the weeds about the level of my intelligence or the source of my information (as if those things make a point valid or invalid). I enjoy the respectful, civil exchange of ideas you and I share. Thank you.
dageir wrote:...Can most of these people travel the world months at a time, have their own cabin in the woods with water, electricity, a sizeable boat/yacht? No? Can they take a year off from work and still make ends meet?
you forgot to add, "...at the expense of others who work their butts off to foot those bills." No; Most of the "American Poor" cannot do those things and no one who cannot afford to pay for those things themselves should enjoy those luxuries.
dageir wrote:Have help in the house?
that depends on your definition of "...help in the house." Many Americans with earnings under the poverty line do pay for their own daycare (the equivalent of a part-time nanny, but not equivalent to a full-time live-in nanny) and for home cleaning services (the equivalent to a part-time maid/maid service but not equivalent to a full-time live-in maid.)
dageir wrote:I believe the middle class of the U.S is shrinking and the "lower" class is increasing.
This depends on which stats you are looking at and the source of said stats. All the stats I've seen agree the middle class is shrinking. Some show the upper
and lower classes expanding, others show only the upper class expanding while the lower and middle classes shrink. And the American Left cry and moan as if more successful Americans is a bad thing. If the stats that say the poor is expanding are correct, then of course that is horrible for the people going from middle to poor, but is that because they are getting poorer or because the poverty line is being raised? And of course, for the person going from middle to upper, the rich expanding is a
great thing!
dageir wrote:People compare themselves to their neighbour, not to the villagers in Zambia
It'd be a much better world if we all compared ourselves to the best we can be rather than to what others are.
Last edited by CaddoPuma on Sat Jun 16, 2018 9:35 pm, edited 4 times in total.