by Mr_Bober » Mon Feb 11, 2019 5:49 pm
Once upon a time we would have been in agreement. But right now, I think only Rage is way too easy to get.
Theft without Vandalism has some huge limitation, and that's what makes it ok for it to be "not that hard" to get fast.
Consider this: for a new character it takes about 1 hour (or less) to set up a claim. 5k (yeomanry + a bunch of things) LP is not that hard to get by discovering stuff and studying a bunch of cone-cows.
Once the claim is up, you'll have to protect it for 8 hours. You can either stay online and try to block anyone from approaching, or cheese it with leantos and alts to prevent anyone from touching it while you're offline.
During those 8 hours, you're powerless. Once the claim is up, people will need Trespassing and Theft to get your things. To defend yourself from it is quite easy.
Build a fence or stone wall around your claim. Don't build gates, just close it all the way.
Sure it can be annoying to have to break a spot and rebuild it every time u have to go out (u can tp back in), but well worth it since it requires only branches or stones.
Once you get "Locks and Bolts", you can safely build a gate and place a lock on it. Tadà! You're safe from anyone without Vandalism. At this point you can safely make some leather and build a palisade, which makes you safer and prevents someone to just break in with vandalism.
Given how much LP are required to get Vandalism, and the fact that now it depends on Rage (which allows you to be killed and Nidbane to be summoned after you), plenty of early game thieves won't bother taking it.
As you can see, it's pretty easy (once the claim is active) to defend against Theft alone. Which is why it makes sense to be able to afford Theft early.
If Theft was much harder to get, nobody would get anything out of it alone, because it's already pretty easy to defend against it.
Also I disagree with the whole "move somewhere else" idea. You only need to move if they bash your claim or break/dump all of your stuff. That's a clear message: GET OUT OF MY AREA.
If they just steal your "valuables" (which can be anything early on: food, hides, curios...), they are just trying to get free stuff, they might not be a problem in the future.