HnH is so good

[Teleskop]

someone is sad because he has to farm moves again after dying

[Uriel]

hunting should be done with bow and arrow, and using stealth to approach the animal.
your stealth will help in aiming speed(simulating the animal not detecting you), and actual moving of the animal will be countered by your marksman skill.
and you should be able to see animals depending on your perception skill, and they will not run from you depending on your stealth skill.
chickens being easiest to see
but mammoths obviously also easy to see. but youll need more than 1 arrow for those
deer and below should be killable with 1 or 2 arrows.
assuming you can find, approch and hit them.

+1 on that in some parts. Hunting should be all about bow and arrow. Steath part is bit to much (noobs would kill them self on invisible animals).

[NOOBY93]

someone is sad because he has to farm moves again after dying

after dying with no moves you mean?

Hunting should be all about bow and arrow. Steath part is bit to much (noobs would kill them self on invisible animals).

Why should hunting only be done with bow and arrow? Let's not take changing the hunting system to such extremes. All combat should be legit when it comes to hunting, otherwise unarmed combat and melee combat become worthless for non-PvP casuals.

[Ysh]

Hunting should be all about bow and arrow. Steath part is bit to much (noobs would kill them self on invisible animals).

But... Why?

Why should hunting only be done with bow and arrow? Let's not take changing the hunting system to such extremes. All combat should be legit when it comes to hunting, otherwise unarmed combat and melee combat become worthless for non-PvP casuals.

Is this strictly bad though? I see PvE player complain ranged is too nerf. I see PvP player complain ranged is too stupid. Simple solution is to make ranged for PvE only and balance this for that and make melee PvP only and balance that for this.

[sMartins]

What would you like to see done with hunting?

Take inspiration from URW....tracking, stealth, trapping and stamina for animals too so you can fatigue them....they should be able to swim, and drink from rivers or stop to rest to restore their stamina. Wounded animals should lose stamina faster...
I guess a lot of work...but maybe one day....

[NOOBY93]

Hunting should be all about bow and arrow. Steath part is bit to much (noobs would kill them self on invisible animals).

But... Why?

Why should hunting only be done with bow and arrow? Let's not take changing the hunting system to such extremes. All combat should be legit when it comes to hunting, otherwise unarmed combat and melee combat become worthless for non-PvP casuals.

Is this strictly bad though? I see PvE player complain ranged is too nerf. I see PvP player complain ranged is too stupid. Simple solution is to make ranged for PvE only and balance this for that and make melee PvP only and balance that for this.

It is strictly bad if PvP combat is literally the only purpose of a skill. Theoretically in a server with only 1 person playing, all mechanics should still be relevant.

Realms don't protect against criminals, but give bonuses. Stealth doesn't protect against getting tracked, but you need it for crafting mirkwoods and other shit. Unarmed combat would be useless because no PvP... And that's it?

What would you like to see done with hunting?

Take inspiration from URW....tracking, stealth, trapping and stamina for animals too so you can fatigue them....they should be able to swim, and drink from rivers or stop to rest to restore their stamina. Wounded animals should lose stamina faster...
I guess a lot of work...but maybe one day....

Please no, never take inspiration from URW, it's а single player turn-based HARDCORE SURVIVAL game, the idea of which is completely different to Haven. just no

That's like asking for a Skyrimesque combat system because it looks cool

it's a different game

[shubla]

Why should hunting only be done with bow and arrow?

Because its outright retarded mechanic to do hunting with punches and swords.
I guess that stuff like mammoths could be hunted by fighting them with something else. But even then the main weapon should be spear, not sword.

[NOOBY93]

Why should hunting only be done with bow and arrow?

Because its outright retarded mechanic to do hunting with puches and sword.

No it's not, removing the usefulness of 2 skills and a whole combat system with moves and everything, from over 50% of the population (casuals) is downright retarded.

[shubla]

Why should hunting only be done with bow and arrow?

Because its outright retarded mechanic to do hunting with puches and sword.

No it's not, removing the usefulness of 2 skills and a whole combat system with moves and everything, from over 50% of the population (casuals) is downright retarded.

They could be used for pvp if one wants to pvp. They would still be useful.

[Ysh]

Is this strictly bad though? I see PvE player complain ranged is too nerf. I see PvP player complain ranged is too stupid. Simple solution is to make ranged for PvE only and balance this for that and make melee PvP only and balance that for this.

It is strictly bad if PvP combat is literally the only purpose of a skill. Theoretically in a server with only 1 person playing, all mechanics should still be relevant.

Realms don't protect against criminals, but give bonuses. Stealth doesn't protect against getting tracked, but you need it for crafting mirkwoods and other shit. Unarmed combat would be useless because no PvP... And that's it?

This is very philosophical point. I think server with only 1 player is outlandish scenario that game design decision does not need to be beholden to. If you feel this is how game should be, I can not argue this opinion, but I do not find it to be compelling argument.