Jalpha wrote:Edit: I may have been confused after scrolling through a page of the Elric brothers formulae. The uncertainty principle seems different in that it states that we can never precisely know both the location and size of any object. This seems to be a result of our broken/unfinished mathematical system, especially after scrolling through a page of obscure formulae. There seems to be no logical reason why the uncertainty principle exists, only a mathematical one.
It's not again, this is excatly what I was talking about.
What you are talking about now it's the first interpretation, the realistic one, that also Einstein supported, that in short says that the wave function is incomplete, we don't know a shit, better we keep looking ... in short this is the realistic position, and the particle was always there even before we measured it.
But nowdays we proved it wrong ... the particle isn't really anywhere, it's the act of measurament that produce the result, just cause we are looking .... when we are not looking we are not able to tell what is going on.
Again I'm not completly sure there isn't anything newer in this regard right now, but from my university book, I remember that experiments have proved the orthodox position. So it's not a limit in our theory, the theory is telling us we won't ever be able to know, very different things. And, you know, quantum mechanics works so far.
That's why I was talking about philosophy, and how we give meaning to our sourrounding that meaning doesn't have, giving meaning to things is a human condition starting with Socrate pretty much, with rationalism and cause-effect principle .... that, of course, also them are not "true" but they work, for us.
Edit:
A pen is not just a pen, little kids that haven't developed the reason yet know it very well. A pen can be used to write, but I can use it as a weapon if I hit you in the eyes, or I can use it for everything, as screwdriver for example or everything.
Reality, "the truth" is not just one meaning for thing, everything means everything or anything means nothing ... just we need a system where evrything has a precise meaning so that we can live togethere and alleviate the anxiety coming from the meaningless reality.
Everytime I take a pen in my hands in 2018 nobody gets scared from my action of taking a pen, cause everybody thinks I'm gonna use it to write, and not to kill someone ..... that isn't true for little kids for example, hitting their friends in the eyes with the pen, that's why parents need to keep watching at them, or for all of us also in the pre-rationalist age, where we were using Totem and Tabù to give meaning to reality, what is good and what is bad ..... after that religions, and so on.
It looks trivial for us nowdays, but it's not trivial .... just cause we internalized it after so many years, but it's an our invention, it's not the reality of things.
Last edited by sMartins on Mon Jul 23, 2018 4:12 pm, edited 2 times in total.