I have fangs, honey, salt water, clay jars, and access to a cauldron, all discovered and collected originally by this character. I have First Aid as well, as listed by the wiki. I'm losing my absolute mind over a -15STR wound that is making it nearly impossible to progress. I spent all day trying to 'discover' honey for a second time, only to find that I had it discovered the whole time. I went down the list and re-discovered every individual ingredient, again. Salt Water was a multi-hour voyage.
The option to craft it doesn't appear in the Medicines list. I have access to Toad Butter, Poultice, and Ant Paste.
Is there some obscure requirement? Do I need Woodsmanship, which would grand the discoveries of other sweeteners? Does Wild Honey not work? I can't imagine what I could be missing.