Changing existing combat skills in meaningful ways

by **overtyped** » Fri Dec 11, 2015 4:38 pm

Instead of adding a new skill for every new weapon, you could change existing skills, so it's less of a clusterfuck. These two weapons were historically used to decent success.

Gauche(parrying dagger)(used in place of a shield) It would increase the duration of parry(maybe double duration?), but you wouldn't be able to shield up.
Buckler:(A small shield) It changes the function of shield up. Instead of 3x melee, it's 1x but it's cooldown is reduced(maybe halfed?). ( it makes sense, because a small shield isn't going to block as well as a full one, but it's more wieldy.

by **Asgaroth22** » Fri Dec 11, 2015 4:42 pm

I like that. If different weapons interacted different with various attacks/blocks, it would only add to the combat diversity.

by **jorb** » Mon Dec 14, 2015 1:58 pm

Adding a new skill for every weapon? A new attack, you mean? Sword already has overlap with both axe and spear, for example. The idea is that the attacks should work with multiple weapons.

by **venatorvenator** » Mon Dec 14, 2015 3:38 pm

jorb wrote:The idea is that the attacks should work with multiple weapons.

Why generalize like that though? It makes combat very linear.
Every weapon had a different application in combat and if that's applied to the game it would make engagement more strategic and diverse. Moves that pierce, damage armor, ignore armor, or which use different stats are what I have in mind.

by **overtyped** » Mon Dec 14, 2015 5:56 pm

jorb wrote:Adding a new skill for every weapon? A new attack, you mean? Sword already has overlap with both axe and spear, for example. The idea is that the attacks should work with multiple weapons.

That is exactly not it.
I'm saying to change existing moves based on what you are wearing.

by **jorb** » Mon Dec 14, 2015 9:20 pm

Modify the deck...?

by **overtyped** » Mon Dec 14, 2015 9:46 pm

jorb wrote:Modify the deck...?

yes, it would make people pay attention to what their opponent is wearing, rather than everyone has the same build.
Well, it's just a interesting idea.

by **jorb** » Mon Dec 14, 2015 10:01 pm

So that the deck is effectively determined by what you are wearing?

by **overtyped** » Mon Dec 14, 2015 10:03 pm

jorb wrote:So that the deck is effectively determined by what you are wearing?

no, just some aspects of it.
Like a small shield, has less cd but less defense when using shield up.
Or a off handed weapon for parrying (instead of a shield), makes your parry skill last longer.

by **jorb** » Mon Dec 14, 2015 10:05 pm

Right. So that the weapon type is relevant more often, quite simply? Sure. That could be more of a thing.

Changing existing combat skills in meaningful ways

Changing existing combat skills in meaningful ways

Re: Changing weapon skills(without adding new ones)

Re: Changing existing combat skills in meaningful ways

Re: Changing existing combat skills in meaningful ways

Re: Changing existing combat skills in meaningful ways

Re: Changing existing combat skills in meaningful ways

Re: Changing existing combat skills in meaningful ways

Re: Changing existing combat skills in meaningful ways

Re: Changing existing combat skills in meaningful ways

Re: Changing existing combat skills in meaningful ways

Who is online