24 hour siege again

[Robben_DuMarsch]

You would still be expressing earnest opinions if they weren't so bad everybody laughing at you made you insecure

It's so cute you think you and your sycophants writing "tl;dr" to my post would make me insecure. I don't know what that says about your own insecurities, but I'll just let the jury stay out on that one.

[ChildhoodObesity]

They should rework siege into a sex minigame.

+1

[Massa]

stop talking about minecraft no one fucking cares

24 hour siege in this bitch of a jungle or this game is a snoozer ass pussyfest

i'm not wasting my young mortal life boating for hours just to get to another faction suck dick fuck thingwalls make it smaller and 24 hour siege

[ChildhoodObesity]

The best way to implement siege IN MY OPINION would be to just re-add the siege claim system from W10 but fix the few SMOL problems it actually had (claim moving and vclaim bashing/expansion of pclaim, etc). This combined with expanding the actual time from minimum 14ish hours to 20-24 would make it reasonably hard while still doable and fix a lot of the other annoying problems (having to ram every single wall in a village of plots being nearly impossible).

I'm not sure why this entire system was scrapped when it only had a few minor flaws. It was the most fleshed out siege system you guys had ever implemented. I can't ever see a better siege system being implemented in this game.

[vatas]

I dunno, either you make Village Banners something you can't break as vandalism at all or third party can come and fake join the siege to break the banner that the siege relies on.

Perhaps the claim (and shield) could simply linger 24 more hours at least after banner is bashed? (Also change so that destruction of village idol causes all banners to be destroyed?)

[Massa]

no more speculation or nonsense

just delete the 5 day meme and change it to 24 hours simple as

[ChildhoodObesity]

no more speculation or nonsense

just delete the 5 day meme and change it to 24 hours simple as

24 hours in this system is literal dogshit trash. the only people youll be able to siege are shitter noob villages who would never put up a fight to stop it in the first place. no way you will pull off a siege on a village that has multiple walls/plots. the old system is 1000x better.

[Massa]

no more speculation or nonsense

just delete the 5 day meme and change it to 24 hours simple as

24 hours in this system is literal dogshit trash. the only people youll be able to siege are shitter noob villages who would never put up a fight to stop it in the first place. no way you will pull off a siege on a village that has multiple walls/plots. the old system is 1000x better.

i'm actually just trying to discourage a bible chapter posted by a 20 total post user from 2015 about his nonsense shit take

jorb and loftar need blinders or they get distracted like horses and they don't need to read those kinds of things when they need to boil shit down, but you're right

[DonVelD]

different opinions add to the cacophony

[Vigilance]

i think at the end of the day it literally doesnt matter because if jorb doesnt want to defend his hermitage for a day no hermit will have to

which is very cringe and not based at all

imo claim shield was the best siege system i experienced because you actually saw people raiding places of substance WITHOUT it being trivial to smash in to everyone/everything else. if we aren't going to go back on reverting to whole previous systems i do think this current system should be culled back down to 24h. i think we're all treading water and wasting our keystrokes because the devs (at least jorb, based on however-many-different-peoples' dms to him i've seen) are probably very well aware that siege is dead as all hell in current implementation.

p.s. this is the absolute easiest world i've ever had to auth/sustain a village in because:
No wballs to worry about
rams are more likely to fall apart on themselves (full numen!)
security is a binary "Yes" or "No"