In this thread primarily I never had the intention to make fun of him. I solely was pointing out what was wrong with his OP. After he started getting hostile towards me I got a a tad hostile to him. But I never went as far to threaten the kid with harassment.
That God___ person has Phinix written all over.
God___ wrote:if you post somthing make it about the fucking post not a bunch of bull shit
!
Erm..I didn't write a "bunch of bull shit" , I gave you perfectly fine criticism. You left out so many things that your original idea was just plain stupid. I gave you a link to the thread that details how to write a proper C&I thread. It's your job as a poster to look at the forum rules before you post. That way you don't wind up banned for a week like your main and wind up having to evade the ban with this account.
God___ wrote:dont even post on his post if he dasnt wont you to post on it makes it easyer for you
I can post on any thread outside of Hel and any thread that's not locked that I can if I choose to. As long as I post within the rules of the forums, then it's fine. Stop evading ban Phinix.
Amanda44 wrote:
When it comes to Phinix you certainly are relentless!
Why you have to consistently pull him to pieces in all of his threads F'Ryu, esp when you can just not read them in the first place, idk.
What I do is whenever I log onto the forums, I click "view new posts" and check out all the new posts that have been from the last time I viewed the forums. I do this because I find it intriguing to see how other people live in this game, to see the "battles" in ICA, to see new ideas that could be implemented, etc. Most of the time I won't post because I have no knowledge of it. But when Phinix posts something, it's usually something anyone can easily point out to him and it takes a bunch of people pointing the answer out to him in order for him to finally get it.
When I saw this thread, I read it and I wasn't gonna comment on it because I didn't wanna deal with the way he types. But then I saw the atrocity of an OP he made. He left out so many details in order to actually make a viable idea. I pointed out to him all the things he should have thought about--as it's evidenced from my posts in this thread.
IE:
I don't see how this is a valid idea.
A
Conecow {one of the easiest curios you can make when you first start} has a base of 50 LP. From your post I assume that the 3LP is the base amount.That's just ridiculous. That would be one of the worst curios ever.
Now, onto the cornbread. What's the benefit? Every food item has
FEP's. But you haven't listed anything for it. Just how to make it. I see now point at all for this food item, let alone the entire thread.
Phinix, you need to read the
suggestion guidelines on how to make a good idea/suggestion for the game.
Phinix wrote:cactus: exploration- 20- ect.
How are you supposed to "harvest" the cactus? Generally they're spiky. Too spiky to just grab them with your bare hands. Unless of course you have to have leather gloves on to grab it. But then how much inventory space would it fill? a 2x2 area? 4x1?
How much fuel would it take to make the dust?
How long does it need to cook for?
In order to find Forageable Curiosities you need a certain amount of perception multiplied by exploration, so you need to list the perception as-well or the perception*exploration amount. That way you can actually find the cactus.
Or, by "etc" you mean that exploration and perception are the same. Which would be 20*20. Which is 400. Which would be up there between a Washed-up Bladderwrack and a Chiming Bluebell.
See, you need to make sure you cover EVERYTHING. That way your idea can actually be seen as a valid idea and not just some random thought. Look at that guideline I linked to a few posts ago, it'll help you avoid this all.
And there's also that which LadyV posted. You have to think about that as-well.
Those two posts were criticizing what the OP was.
