Patchouli_Knowledge wrote:I think the big difference between my idea and keyn_thror's is that mine is available to all villages, small or large, and is not so resource hungry but not permanent and is not an end game type.
The only ideas brought up that make it only available to large villages is the sacrifice mechanic and that could be based off of several factors and may just be something that takes time and not something complex. And where do you say yours aren't permanent? Is the idea that you hang items from the idol for the bonuses for only a temporary amount of time? Because that's resource hungry just in a different form.
Also for not being end game. A simple bonus to crop quality yield immediately makes all large villages make a satellite village for it's farm just to get that bonus. Same goes for crafting. A 1-5 quality bonus is a lot when you are talking about the late game. Though adding stats (if flat and not percentages) is nice and may cause diversities of player through their village choice, the problem becomes that the combat alts will all be at one village that has the stat buffs, crafters (maybe of different types) at another, and farmers at yet another. This causes the village bonuses to become very late game and give small, but signification, bonuses to very large and/or organized villages.
I don't want to be a complete downer about this idea I do like it. I just know that if you make it anything other than extremely minor buffs, I had a list on the other thread, then it will probably just be a thing of rich get richer and poor stay poor, which isn't a bad thing but often something that is avoided.
Edit:
cloakblade wrote:On this note ideas that wouldn't be OP would be ones such as:
Increased stamina regen
Increased HP regen
Hunger Modifiers (maybe?)
Increased Happiness (won't do anything until happiness is introduced)
Hunger drain
Travel Weariness drain (like sleeping in a bed does)
Increased Movement (this maybe a little overpowered)
None of these are too broken and give only slight advantages. All of them could drain more authority too.
A.K.A. Suddo