New Brodgar - War of Newb Defense

[CloudJhi]

I like how everyone's assigning worth to their words.
Does anyone in this thread actually expect anyone to respect their words when they're on opposite sides of a conflict? Lol.

Idk dole, I would really have wanted the truce before - honestly was never online at the right times to actually participate in anything too fun. Then Brodgar straight up asked us for our master keys - we couldn't just agree to that now could we?

A clay spot would've been easy to give up tbh, but our whole town back then? Lol.

[RedKGB]

Once again the newb killer and raider thinks his word is worth something.

Im just opening up a discussion, its brodgars word that you would have.

What discussion is that? They killed Ry, it is dead. You even trying to open talks on their behalf shows that you in fact do speak for them. As you have done from the very start of this thread.

[overtyped]

What discussion is that? They killed Ry, it is dead. You even trying to open talks on their behalf shows that you in fact do speak for them. As you have done from the very start of this thread.

Nope, im just creating dialogue, i dont have the last say.

[molenga]

Lol at the moral outrage of farmers in ryleh who got killed. Never heard of guilt by association?

I didn´t get killed mate, my friends did, I just got to watch my village be destroyed, my friends killed and the ones that survived are either quiting or leaving, im not having a moral outrage either, just sad that all my friends are gone.

In a way, this feels a lot like when my plot got raided in W7 and all my friends quit because of it, it just feels quite sad that im always left alone after shit hits the fan.

[CloudJhi]

Nope, im just creating dialogue, i dont have the last say.

You should handle negotiations for future conflicts then
Your prices are far more reasonable compared to Robbens - had you been the one in the talks something may have actually been worked out.

[RedKGB]

What discussion is that? They killed Ry, it is dead. You even trying to open talks on their behalf shows that you in fact do speak for them. As you have done from the very start of this thread.

Nope, im just creating dialogue, i dont have the last say.

Yet you have the first say, and how does not effect everything afterwards?

[Onep]

I like how everyone's assigning worth to their words.
Does anyone in this thread actually expect anyone to respect their words when they're on opposite sides of a conflict? Lol.

Idk dole, I would really have wanted the truce before - honestly was never online at the right times to actually participate in anything too fun. Then Brodgar straight up asked us for our master keys - we couldn't just agree to that now could we?

A clay spot would've been easy to give up tbh, but our whole town back then? Lol.

I don't know, people sure seem to expect their text to carry weight. Makes me think of a saying: you don't need to explain yourself, your friends don't need it and your enemies won't believe you.

[Archiplex]

For what it's worth- the conversations (while a majority were mostly 1 sided on my end) between jennyismygf and you, eggplant, and a few others were pretty entertaining.

oh wait, wait, wait! eggplant = Archiplex?! now that changes my pov a bit now...

Haha no, no.

He meant that on the alts he brought over, he talked with myself, Eggplant and some others.

[dchow002]

Well, before getting the location i would have to run it by robben, if he agreed then yes.

So more or less, "If I get what I want, I'll leave you alone"?

(premise, clay location is what you want, and a truce is being left alone).

You realize that sounds awfully like a bully?

If you give me your lunch money, x y z, I'll leave you alone?

Well, you started this war, and your word is worthless. The only way to keep a peace is if you gave us something valuable.
That way, youd have second thoughts about ever breaking the truce.

Excuse me, but I'm not in any way part of this war? I actually had a message to Robbin asking about requirements to join maybe a month ago? But reading the posts put out by you two turned me off (best for both of us). Not everyone who points out fallacies are "part of your enemy." I'm just someone who takes displeasure in inconsistent and illogical arguments.

The only way to keep peace is to give us something valuable? That's more or less asking for tribute / subjugation. And it doesn't matter who started the war and whatnot (I don't know who started the war). Two wrongs may make it even but they most certainly don't make it right. A true nation seeking peace does not make demands for concession other than peace.

To be frank, the manner in which you try so hard (and illogically at times) to claim a moral high ground is morally reprehensible.

I have no issue with people raiding, wars, being raided. But don't claim to be a "peaceful nation defending newbs" when in fact you are truly a bully.

Bully: use of superior strength or influence to intimidate (someone), typically to force him or her to do what one wants. (demanding the clay for peace)

[Bramson]

Since this thread is no longer New Brodgar, in terms of actually being a new player haven, a change of title is in order to change this topic permanently to "New Brodger, a Coalition of Dole" to be less confusing to new players.

From this point on and to all future worlds, New Brodgar will never be associated as a new player haven.