Criminals and owning scents

[VDZ]

Alternatively, you could perhaps attack and ko the person if you are holding their scent, and then right click the murder stench onto their body to kill them; meaning no murder spent on your end

Two wrongs don't make a right. If you kill me for committing a crime against you, why should I not be allowed to avenge myself?

[Zeler]

Alternatively, you could perhaps attack and ko the person if you are holding their scent, and then right click the murder stench onto their body to kill them; meaning no murder spent on your end

Two wrongs don't make a right. If you kill me for committing a crime against you, why should I not be allowed to avenge myself?

Should a person executing death penalty be convicted afterwards?


Also, the scent execurion should have somewhat longish timer to prevent abuse in heat of combat.

[Glorthan]

Alternatively, you could perhaps attack and ko the person if you are holding their scent, and then right click the murder stench onto their body to kill them; meaning no murder spent on your end

Two wrongs don't make a right. If you kill me for committing a crime against you, why should I not be allowed to avenge myself?

Ranging and banditry are completely different types of activity. I don't see why ranging would be considered a crime, given that the intent is to purge those that leave scents, not generate more.

[VDZ]

Ranging and banditry are completely different types of activity. I don't see why ranging would be considered a crime, given that the intent is to purge those that leave scents, not generate more.

You are assuming that all non-ranging murders are banditry. What if someone steals from my Salt node, I catch him in the act, he flees, and I chase him down and kill him on unclaimed land? I killed a criminal, but I still left a murder scent. Should someone be able to kill me in response without me being able to do anything about it or avenge myself?

Should a person executing death penalty be convicted afterwards?

An execution is when a society determines one of its members must die for their acts. I am not part of whatever social group wants me dead for wronging them; for them to kill me is either a murder or an act of war.

[Granger]

Ranging and banditry are completely different types of activity. I don't see why ranging would be considered a crime, given that the intent is to purge those that leave scents, not generate more.

You are assuming that all non-ranging murders are banditry. What if someone steals from my Salt node, I catch him in the act, he flees, and I chase him down and kill him on unclaimed land? I killed a criminal, but I still left a murder scent. Should someone be able to kill me in response without me being able to do anything about it or avenge myself?
Send a nidbane.

An execution is when a society determines one of its members must die for their acts. I am not part of whatever social group wants me dead for wronging them; for them to kill me is either a murder or an act of war.

Given the current geopolitical landscape it's simply collateral damage, in case you're not in the right country.

[Tamalak]

Alternatively, you could perhaps attack and ko the person if you are holding their scent, and then right click the murder stench onto their body to kill them; meaning no murder spent on your end

Two wrongs don't make a right. If you kill me for committing a crime against you, why should I not be allowed to avenge myself?

Should a person executing death penalty be convicted afterwards?


Also, the scent execurion should have somewhat longish timer to prevent abuse in heat of combat.

FFS people. A "crime" in Haven does not mean something that is wrong or illegal. All it means is an action that leaves evidence. The name really needs to be changed..

[jordancoles]

Bump for future updates

[jordancoles]

Bump

[Teleskop]

if you kill a murderer the amount of murderers stays the same

[jordancoles]

if you kill a murderer the amount of murderers stays the same

Read the post nerd