
I think it should have "seafood" or "bakery" in the name.
EDIT:
Abandoned the quest and that's what I've got:




I'd guess he had no access to eels (or lacked a spot where one could comfortably get 17 of them.)altynbaevik wrote:Did you try to eat Ring of Brodgar seafood?
http://ringofbrodgar.com/wiki/Ring_of_Brodgar_(Seafood)